Old First Church
New York, New Jersey
Last updated May 2026
~236
estimated members
Based on ARDA 2020 data, this is likely one of 20 Presbyterian congregations in Monmouth County, NJ, with an average size of approximately 236 members. Presbyterian accounts for 1% of the county's 384 congregations.
Source: ARDA 2020 Religious Congregations & Membership Study
Nearby churches in New York
Middletown Reformed Church
0.3 miReformed
121 Kings Hwy
King of Kings Lutheran Church
1.4 miLutheran
250 Harmony Rd
Saint Mary, Mother of God Church
1.5 miCatholic
19 Cherry Tree Farm Rd
Our Lady of the Most Blessed Sacrament Shrine
1.5 miNon-Denominational
26 Leonardville Rd
Middletown United Methodist Church
2.2 miMethodist
924 Middletown-Lincroft Rd
Middletown Assembly of God
2.5 mi628 Palmer Ave, Middletown Township, NJ 07748