Setauket Presbyterian Church

East Setauket, New York

Address

5 Caroline Ave

Denomination

Presbyterian

Last updated September 2026

Visit websiteOpen in Google Maps
Map showing location of Setauket Presbyterian Church
Open in Google Maps

100-200

estimated members

This is likely one of 35 Presbyterian congregations in Suffolk County, NY. Presbyterian accounts for 1% of the county's 726 congregations.

This estimate comes from ARDA 2020 data for churches of this size and denomination in the county.

Nearby churches in East Setauket

Setauket Presbyterian Church Graveyard

95 ft

Presbyterian

5 Caroline Ave

Setauket Presbyterian Church Sundial

234 ft

Presbyterian

Caroline Episcopal Church

432 ft

Episcopal

1 Dyke Rd

Caroline Church of Brookhaven

445 ft

Episcopal

Setauket-East Setauket, 11733

Monastery of the Holy Cross

0.3 mi

Non-Denominational

140 Main St

Setauket United Methodist Church

0.4 mi

Methodist

Setauket-East Setauket, 11733

Explore more

More Presbyterian churches in New YorkMore churches in New YorkPresbyterian churches in United States

Continue on BibleTimes

Free scholarly tools for reading and studying Scripture.

Read the BibleRead any passage in the King James Version with cross-references and scholarly notes.Verse of the DayA passage each day, with context and tradition readings.Bible Study LibraryPericopes, doctrine, sacraments, and figures with scholarly context.About Presbyterian beliefsWhat presbyterian churches believe, their history, and how they compare.