Setauket Presbyterian Church
East Setauket, New York
Address
5 Caroline AveDenomination
PresbyterianLast updated September 2026
100-500
estimated members
This is likely one of 35 Presbyterian congregations in Suffolk County, NY. Presbyterian accounts for 5% of the county's 726 congregations.
This estimate comes from ARDA 2020 data for churches of this size and denomination in the county.
Nearby churches in East Setauket
Setauket Presbyterian Church Sundial
234 ftPresbyterian
5 Caroline Ave
Caroline Episcopal Church
432 ftEpiscopal
1 Dyke Rd
Caroline Church of Brookhaven
445 ftEpiscopal
Setauket-East Setauket
Monastery of the Holy Cross
0.3 miNon-Denominational
140 Main St
Setauket United Methodist Church
0.4 miMethodist
Setauket-East Setauket
Three Village Church
0.6 miOther
322 Main St