Our Lady of the Isle Church
Shelter Island Heights, New York
Denomination
CatholicPhone
(631) 749-0001Service times
Sun
8:00 AM Mass10:00 AM Mass5:00 PM Mass
Mon–Fri
9:00 AM Mass
Sat
3:00 PM Confession5:00 PM Mass
Last updated September 2026
5,000-20,000
estimated members
This is likely one of 72 Catholic congregations in Suffolk County, NY. Catholic accounts for 10% of the county's 726 congregations.
This estimate comes from ARDA 2020 data for churches of this size and denomination in the county.
Your digital sanctuary for spiritual growth.
Continue on BibleTimes
Free scholarly tools for reading and studying Scripture.
Create free account