Luke 18:9-14 · Luke

Pharisee & Tax Collector

Jesus tells a parable about two men who went to the temple to pray: a Pharisee and a tax collector. The Pharisee boasts about his righteousness, while the tax collector humbly asks for God's mercy. Jesus concludes that the tax collector is justified rather than the Pharisee.

Summary

This passage from the Gospel of Luke is a parable told by Jesus to address those who were confident in their own righteousness and looked down on others (Luke 18:9). The setting is a temple, where two men go to pray. One is a Pharisee, a member of a religious group known for strict adherence to the law, and the other is a tax collector, often viewed as a sinner and collaborator with Roman occupiers. The parable begins by introducing these two contrasting characters and their purpose for being in the temple.

In the temple, the Pharisee stands and prays, expressing gratitude that he is not like other people, whom he labels as extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or like the tax collector present (Luke 18:11). He lists his religious practices, such as fasting twice a week and giving tithes of all he possesses (Luke 18:12). In contrast, the tax collector stands at a distance, not daring to look up to heaven. Instead, he beats his chest and prays for mercy, acknowledging himself as a sinner (Luke 18:13). The actions and attitudes of the two men are starkly different, highlighting their respective approaches to prayer and self-perception.

The passage concludes with Jesus stating that the tax collector, rather than the Pharisee, goes home justified before God (Luke 18:14). The final verse establishes the principle that those who exalt themselves will be humbled, while those who humble themselves will be exalted. This conclusion underscores the outcome of the parable, focusing on the significance of humility and repentance in one's relationship with God.

Chiastic structure

ⓘ
A

Luke 18:11-12

“The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, God, I thank thee, that I am not as other men...”

B

Luke 18:13

“And the publican, standing afar off, would not lift up so much as eyes unto heaven, but smote upon his breast, saying, God be merciful to me a sinner.”

A'

Luke 18:14

“I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other...”

A and A' mirror each other through the theme of self-exaltation versus humility and the resulting justification.

Interpretation and theological stakes

The main conclusion of the passage is that true justification before God comes not from self-righteousness or religious observance, but from humility and acknowledgment of one's own sinfulness. Jesus uses the parable to contrast the self-satisfied righteousness of the Pharisee with the humble repentance of the tax collector. The Pharisee's prayer is a self-congratulatory list of his religious deeds, while the tax collector's prayer is a simple plea for mercy. Jesus concludes that the tax collector, not the Pharisee, returns home justified, emphasizing that humility leads to exaltation before God (Luke 18:14).

The Catholic interpretation sees this passage as highlighting the role of both faith and works in justification. The Pharisee's actions, such as fasting and tithing, are seen as necessary but insufficient on their own. His failure lies in his attitude of superiority and lack of genuine humility, not in the deeds themselves. This reading finds support in the Pharisee's focus on his own righteousness (Luke 18:11-12). Catholics argue that while good works are important, they must be accompanied by a humble heart and sincere faith. Thus, the tax collector's humility becomes the necessary complement to righteous action, demonstrating that both are integral to true justification.

In contrast, the Protestant interpretation emphasizes justification by faith alone, drawing a sharp distinction between the Pharisee's reliance on his own deeds and the tax collector's faith-based plea for mercy. This view focuses on the tax collector's admission of sin and his appeal to God's mercy as the sole basis for justification (Luke 18:13). Protestants argue that the Pharisee's self-righteous attitude exemplifies the futility of relying on works for salvation. The passage is read as a clear message that faith, exemplified by the tax collector's humble request for mercy, is the only path to being justified before God.

Considering both interpretations, the passage underscores a transformative understanding of justification. It suggests that neither faith nor works alone suffice; rather, the heart's posture before God is crucial. The Pharisee's actions, though commendable, lack the essential element of humility, whereas the tax collector's faith expresses itself through a humble acknowledgment of sin. This synthesis challenges believers to pursue a faith that is lived out through humility, aligning their hearts with God's grace rather than relying solely on ritualistic observance or mere belief.

Continue reading with a Scholar plan

Upgrade to Scholar